Behaviorally informed policies for household financial decisionmaking

by Brigitte C. Madrian, Hal E. Hershfield, Abigail B. Sussman, Saurabh Bhargava, Jeremy Burke, Scott A. Huettel, Julian Jamison, Eric J. Johnson, John G. Lynch, Stephan Meier, Scott Rick, Suzanne B. Shu
August 15, 2017

Author Affiliation

The authors were members of the BSPA Working
Group on Financial Decisionmaking.
Madrian: Harvard University. Hershfield: University
of California, Los Angeles. Sussman:
University of Chicago. Bhargava: Carnegie
Mellon University. Burke: University of Southern
California. Huettel: Duke University. Jamison:
The World Bank. Johnson: Columbia University.
Lynch: University of Colorado Boulder.
Meier: Columbia University. Rick: University
of Michigan. Shu: University of California,
Los Angeles. Corresponding author’s e-mail:
[email protected].


1. Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System. (2016, June 8). Financial
accounts of the United States: Flow of
funds, balance sheets, and integrated
macroeconomic accounts [Federal
Reserve statistical release]. Retrieved
2. U.S. Office of Personnel Management.
(n.d.). Historical federal workforce tables:
Total government employment since
1962. Retrieved from https://perma.
3. Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., & Madrian, B.
C. (2011). $100 bills on the sidewalk:
Violations of no-arbitrage in 401(k)
accounts. The Review of Economics and
Statistics, 113, 748–763.
4. Duarte, F., & Hastings, J. S. (2012).
Fettered consumers and sophisticated
firms: Evidence from Mexico’s privatized
social security market (NBER Working
Paper No. 18582). Cambridge, MA:
National Bureau of Economic Research.
5. Hastings, J. S., Hortacsu, A., & Syverson,
C. (2013). Advertising and competition
in privatized social security: The case
of Mexico (NBER Working Paper No.
18881). Cambridge, MA: National Bureau
of Economic Research.
6. Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., & Madrian, B. C.
(2009). Why does the law of one price
fail? An experiment on index mutual
funds. Review of Financial Studies, 23,
7. Campbell, J. Y. (2006). Household
finance. Journal of Finance, 61,
8. Odean, T. (1998). Are investors reluctant
to realize their losses? Journal of
Finance, 53, 1775–1798.
9. Anagol, S., Cole, S., & Sarkar, S.
(2017). Understanding the advice
of commissions-motivated agents:
Evidence from the Indian life insurance
market. Review of Economics and
Statistics, 99, 1–15.
10. Gross, D. B., & Souleles, N. S. (2002). Do
liquidity constraints and interest rates
matter for consumer behavior? Evidence
from credit card data. The Quarterly
Journal of Economics, 117, 149–185.
11. Barber, B., & Odean, T. (2004). Are
individual investors tax savvy? Evidence
from retail and discount brokerage
accounts. Journal of Public Economics,
88, 419–442.
12. Bergstresser, D., & Poterba, J. (2004).
Asset allocation and asset location:
Household evidence from the Survey of
Consumer Finances. Journal of Public
Economics, 88, 1893–1915.
13. Huang, G., Amromin, J., & Sialm, C.
(2007). The tradeoff between mortgage
prepayments and tax-deferred
retirement savings. Journal of Public
Economics, 91, 2014–2040.
14. Agarwal, S., Driscoll, J., Gabaix, X., &
Laibson, D. (2009). The age of reason:
Financial decisions over the life cycle
and implications for regulation.
Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,
2009(2), 51–101.
15. Agarwal, S., Skiba, P., & Tobacman, J.
(2009). Payday loans and credit cards:
New liquidity and credit scoring puzzles?
American Economic Review: Papers and
Proceedings, 99, 412–417.
16. Hauser, J. R. (1978). Testing the
accuracy, usefulness, and significance
of probabilistic choice models: An
information-theoretic approach.
Operations Research, 26, 406–421.
17. Alba, J. W., Hutchinson, J., & Lynch, J.
G. (1991). Memory and decision making.
In T. S. Robertson & H. H. Kassarjian
(Eds.), Handbook of consumer behavior
(pp. 1–49). Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
18. Spiller, S. A. (2011). Opportunity cost
consideration. Journal of Consumer
Research, 38, 595–610.
19. Woodward, S. E., & Hall, R. E. (2012).
Diagnosing consumer confusion and
sub-optimal shopping effort: Theory and
mortgage-market evidence. American
Economic Review, 102, 3249–3276.
20. Barr, M. S., Mullanaithan, S., & Shafir,
E. (2009). The case for behaviorally
informed regulation. In D. Moss & J.
Cistierno (Eds.), New perspectives on
regulation (pp. 25–61). Cambridge, MA:
The Tobin Project.
21. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
(2015, January). Consumers’ mortgage
shopping experience. Retrieved from
22. Stango, V., & Zinman, J. (2014). Limited
and varying consumer attention:
Evidence from shocks to the salience of
bank overdraft fees. Review of Financial
Studies, 27, 990–1030.
23. Fernandes, D., Lynch, J. G., &
Netemeyer, R. G. (2014). Financial
literacy, financial education, and
downstream financial behaviors.
Management Science, 60, 1861–1883.
24. Bartels, D. M., & Urminsky, O. (2015).
To know and to care: How awareness
and valuation of the future jointly
shape consumer spending. Journal of
Consumer Research, 41, 1469–1485.
25. Shu, S. B., Zeithammer, R., & Payne, J.
W. (2016). Consumer preferences for
annuity attributes: Beyond net present
value. Journal of Marketing Research,
52, 240–262.
26. Malmendier, U., & Nagel, S. (2011).
Depression babies: Do macroeconomic
experiences affect risk taking? The
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126,
27. Golman, R., Hagmann, D., &
Loewenstein, G. (2017). Information
avoidance. Journal of Economic
Literature, 55, 96–135.
28. Lusardi, A., & Mitchell, O. S. (2011).
Financial literacy around the world: An
overview. Journal of Pension Economics
and Finance, 10, 497–508.
29. McKenzie, C. R., & Liersch, M. J. (2011).
Misunderstanding savings growth:
Implications for retirement savings
behavior. Journal of Marketing Research,
48, S1–S13.
30. Soll, J. B., Keeney, R. L., & Larrick, R. P.
(2013). Consumer misunderstanding of
credit card use, payments, and debt:
Causes and solutions. Journal of Public
Policy and Marketing, 32, 66–81.
31. Stango, V., & Zinman, J. (2009).
Exponential growth bias and household
finance. Journal of Finance, 64,
32. Tversky, A., & Shafir, E. (1992). Choice
under conflict: The dynamics of deferred
decision. Psychological Science, 3,
33. Lacko, J. M., & Pappalardo, J. K. (2010).
The failure and promise of mandated
consumer mortgage disclosures:
Evidence from qualitative interviews and
a controlled experiment with mortgage
borrowers. American Economic Review,
100, 516–521.
34. Benaratzi, S., & Thaler, R. H. (2001).
Naïve diversification strategies in defined
contribution saving plans. American
Economic Review, 91, 79–98.
35. Read, D., & Loewenstein, G. (1995).
Diversification bias: Explaining the
discrepancy in variety seeking between
combined and separated choices.
Journal of Experimental Psychology:
Applied, 1, 34–49.
36. Ericson, K. M. M., White, J. M., Laibson,
D., & Cohen, J. D. (2015). Money earlier
or later? Simple heuristics explain
intertemporal choices better than
delay discounting does. Psychological
Science, 26, 826–833.
38 behavioral science & policy | volume 3 issue 1 2017
37. Madrian, B. C., & Shea, D. F. (2001). The
power of suggestion: Inertia in 401(k)
participation and savings behavior. The
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 116,
38. Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (1979).
Prospect theory: An analysis of decision
under risk. Econometrica, 47, 263–292.
39. Shefrin, H., & Statman, M. (1995). The
disposition to sell winners too early
and ride losers too long: Theory and
evidence. Journal of Finance, 40,
40. Odean, T. (1998). Are investors reluctant
to realize their losses? Journal of
Finance, 53, 1775–1798.
41. Genesove, D., & Mayer, C. (2001). Loss
aversion and seller behavior: Evidence
from the housing market. The Quarterly
Journal of Economics, 116, 1233–1260.
42. Chabris, C. F., Laibson, D., & Schuldt,
J. P. (2008). Intertemporal choice. In
S. N. Durlauf & L. E. Blume (Eds.), The
new Palgrave dictionary of economics
(2nd ed.). Retrieved from http://
43. Hershfield, H. E., Goldstein, D. G.,
Sharpe, W. F., Fox, J., Yeykelis, L.,
Carstensen, L. L., & Bailenson, J. N.
(2011). Increasing saving behavior
through age-progressed renderings
of the future self. Journal of Marketing
Research, 48, S23–S37.
44. Tversky, A., & Kahneman, D. (1992).
Advances in prospect theory:
Cumulative representation of
uncertainty. Journal of Risk and
Uncertainty, 5, 297–323.
45. Payne, J. W., Sagara, N., Shu, S. B.,
Appelt, K. C., & Johnson, E. J. (2013).
Life expectancy as a constructed belief:
Evidence of a live-to or die-by framing
effect. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty,
46, 27–50.
46. Sussman, A. B., & Olivola, C. Y. (2011).
Axe the tax: Taxes are disliked more than
equivalent costs. Journal of Marketing
Research, 48, S91–S101.
47. Johnson, E. J., Haubl, G., & Keinan,
A. (2007). Aspects of endowment: A
query theory. Journal of Experimental
Psychology: Learning, Memory, and
Cognition, 33, 461–474.
48. Weber, E. U., Johnson, E. J., Milch, K. F.,
Chang, H., Brodscholl, J. C., & Goldstein,
D. G. (2007). Asymmetric discounting in
intertemporal choice: A query–theory
account. Psychological Science, 18,
49. Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., & Madrian, B. C.
(2009). Mental accounting in portfolio
choice: Evidence from a flypaper
effect. American Economic Review, 99,
50. Sussman, A. B., & O’Brien, R. L. (2016).
Knowing when to spend: Unintended
financial consequences of earmarking to
encourage savings. Journal of Marketing
Research, 53, 790–803.
51. Lerner, J. S., Li, Y., Valdesolo, P., &
Kassam, K. (2015). Emotion and decision
making. Annual Review of Psychology,
66, 799–823.
52. Hirschleifer, D., & Shumway, T. (2003).
Good day sunshine: Stock returns and
the weather. Journal of Finance, 58,
53. McKenzie, C. R., Liersch, M.
J., & Finkelstein, M. R. (2006).
Recommendations implicit in policy
defaults. Psychological Science, 17,
54. Schwartz, J., Luce, M. F., & Ariely, D.
(2011). Are consumers too trusting?
The effects of relationships with expert
advisers. Journal of Marketing Research,
48, S163–S174.
55. Cain, D. M., Loewenstein, G., & Moore,
D. A. (2005). The dirt on coming clean:
Perverse effects of disclosing conflicts
of interest. Journal of Legal Studies, 34,
56. Guiso, L., Sapienza, P., & Zingales,
L. (2008). Trusting the stock market.
Journal of Finance, 63, 2557–2600.
57. Chetty, R., Friedman, J. N., & Saez, E.
(2013). Using differences in knowledge
across neighborhoods to uncover
the impacts of the EITC on earnings.
American Economic Review, 103,
58. Kast, F., Meier, S., & Pomeranz, D. (2016).
Saving more in groups: Experimental
evidence from Chile (Working Paper
12-060). Cambridge, MA: Harvard
Business School.
59. Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D.,
Madrian, B. C., & Milkman, K. L. (2015).
The effect of providing peer information
on retirement savings decisions. Journal
of Finance, 70, 1161–1201.
60. Bertrand, M., & Morse, A. (2016).
Trickle-down consumption. Review of
Economics and Statistics, 98, 863–879.
61. Kuhn, P., Kooreman, P., Soetevent, A., &
Kapteyn, A. (2011). The effects of lottery
prizes on winners and their neighbors:
Evidence from the Dutch postcode
lottery. American Economic Review, 101,
62. Carroll, G., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D.,
Madrian, B. C., & Metrick, A. (2009).
Optimal defaults and active decisions.
The Quarterly Journal of Economics,
124, 1639–1674.
63. Dai, H., Milkman, K. L., & Riis, J. (2014).
The fresh start effect: Temporal
landmarks motivate aspirational
behavior. Management Science, 60,
64. Executive Office of the President,
National Science and Technology
Council. (2015, September). Social
and Behavioral Sciences Team annual
report. Retrieved from
65. Federal Retirement Thrift Investment
Board. (2016, January). Thrift Savings
Plan election form (Form TSP-U-1).
Retrieved from
66. Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., &
Madrian, B. C. (2013). Simplification and
saving. Journal of Economic Behavior
and Organizations, 95, 130–145.
67. Alter, A. L., & Hershfield, H. E. (2014).
People search for meaning when
they approach a new decade in
chronological age. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences, USA, 111,
68. Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., &
Madrian, B. C. (2017). Does front-loading
taxation increase savings? Evidence from
Roth 401(k) introductions. Journal of
Public Economics, 151, 84–95.
69. Johnson, E., Appelt, K., Knoll, M.,
& Westfall, J. (2016). Preference
checklists: Selective and effective choice
architecture for retirement decisions
(Research Dialogue Issue No. 127).
Retrieved from TIAA-CREF website:
70. Bronshtein, G., Scott, J., Shoven, J. B., &
Slavov, S. N. (2016). Leaving big money
on the table: Arbitrage opportunities in
delaying Social Security (NBER Working
Paper No. 22853). Cambridge, MA:
National Bureau of Economic Research.
71. Goda, G. S., Manchester, C. F., &
Sojourner, A. J. (2014). What will my
account be worth? Experimental
evidence on how retirement income
projections affect saving. Journal of
Public Economics, 119, 80–92.
a publication of the behavioral science & policy association 39
72. Goldstein, D. G., Hershfield, H. E., &
Benartzi, S. (2016). The illusion of wealth
and its reversal. Journal of Marketing
Research, 53, 804–813.
73. Levi, Y. (2016). Information architecture
and intertemporal choice: A randomized
field experiment in the United States
[Working paper]. Los Angeles: University
of Southern California, Marshall School
of Business.
74. Beshears, J., Choi, J. J., Laibson, D.,
Madrian, B. C., & Zeldes, S. P. (2014).
What makes annuitization more
appealing? Journal of Public Economics,
116, 2–16.
75. Brown, J. R., Kling, J. R., Mullainathan,
S., & Wrobel, M. V. (2008). Why don’t
people insure late-life consumption?
A framing explanation of the underannuitization
puzzle. American
Economic Review Papers and
Proceedings, 98, 304–309.
76. Brown, J. R., Kapteyn, A., & Mitchell, O.
S. (2016). Framing and claiming: How
information-framing affects expected
Social Security claiming behavior.
Journal of Risk and Insurance, 83,
77. Shu, S. B., Zeithammer, R., & Payne, J.
W. (2016). Consumer preferences for
annuity attributes: Beyond net present
value. Journal of Marketing Research,
53, 240–262.
78. Sallie Mae. (2015). How America saves
for college 2016. Retrieved from https://
79. Board of Governors of the Federal
Reserve System. (2016, May). Report
on the economic well-being of
U.S. households in 2015. Retrieved
from https://www.federalreserve.
80. Tax Policy Center. (2016). The Tax
Policy Center’s briefing book: What
is the earned income tax credit
(EITC)? Retrieved from http://www.
81. Duflo, E., Gale, W., Liebman, J., Orszag,
P., & Saez, E. (2006). Saving incentives
for low- and middle-income families:
Evidence from a field experiment with
H&R Block. The Quarterly Journal of
Economics, 121, 1311–1346.
82. Grinstein-Weiss, M., Russell, B. D.,
Gale, W. G., Key, C., & Ariely, D. (2016).
Behavioral interventions to increase
tax-time saving: Evidence from a
national randomized trial. Journal of
Consumer Affairs, 51, 3–26.
83. Saez, E. (2009). Details matter: The
impact of presentation and information
on the take-up of financial incentives for
retirement saving. American Economic
Journal: Economic Policy, 1(1), 204–228.
84. Jones, D., & Mahajan, A. (2015). Timeinconsistency
and saving: Experimental
evidence from low-income tax filers
(NBER Working Paper No. 21272).
Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of
Economic Research.
85. Rogers, T., Milkman, K. L., John, L.
K., & Norton, M. (2016). Beyond good
intentions: Prompting people to make
plans improves follow-through on
important tasks. Behavioral Science &
Policy, 1(2), 33–41.
86. U.S. Department of the Treasury. (2012,
August). Direct deposit sign-up form
(OMB No. 1510-0007). Retrieved from
87. Amar, M., Ariely, D., Ayal, S., Cryder, C.,
& Rick, S. (2011). Winning the battle but
losing the war: The psychology of debt
management. Journal of Marketing
Research, 48, S38–S50.
88. Bertrand, M., & Morse, A. (2011).
Information disclosure, cognitive biases,
and payday borrowing. Journal of
Finance, 66, 1865–1893.
89. Agarwal, S., Driscoll, J. C., & Laibson, D.
(2013). Optimal morgage refinancing: A
closed-form solution. Journal of Money,
Credit and Banking, 45, 591–662.
90. Johnson, E. J., Meier, S., & Toubia, O.
(2015). Money left on the kitchen table:
Exploring sluggish mortgage refinancing
using administrative data, surveys, and
field experiments [Working paper]. New
York, NY: Columbia University Graduate
School of Business.
91. U.S. Department of Education. (n.d.).
College scorecard [Version 1.9.8].
Retrieved from https://collegescorecard.
92. U.S. Department of Education. (n.d.).
College affordability and transparency
center. Retrieved from http://collegecost.
93. U.S. Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau & U.S. Department of Education.
(n.d.). [Sample shopping sheet to help
rate colleges.]. Retrieved from http://
94. Hastings, J., Neilson, C. A., &
Zimmerman, S. D. (2015). The effects
of earnings disclosures on college
enrollment decisions (NBER Working
Paper No. 21300). Cambridge, MA:
National Bureau of Economic Research.
95. Iowa Student Loan. (2017). Student loan
game plan. Retrieved from http://www.
96. U.S. Department of the Treasury.
(2017). EITC participation rate by states.
Retrieved from https://www.eitc.irs.
97. Crouse, G., & Waters, A. (with Hauan,
S., Macartney, S., & Swenson, K.).
(2014). Welfare indicators and risk
factors: Thirteenth report to Congress.
Retrieved from Office of the Assistant
Secretary for Planning and Evaluation
98. Currie, J. (2006). The take-up of social
benefits. In A. Auerbach, D. Card, & J.
Quigley (Eds.), Poverty, the distribution
of income, and public policy (pp.
80–148). New York, NY: Russell Sage
99. Bhargava, S., & Manoli, D. (2015).
Psychological frictions and the
incomplete take-up of social benefits:
Evidence from an IRS field experiment.
American Economic Review, 105,
100. Bettinger, E. P., Long, B. T., Oreopoulos,
P., & Sanbonmatsu, L. (2012). The
role of application assistance and
information in college decisions:
Results from the H&R Block FAFSA
experiment. The Quarterly Journal of
Economics, 127, 1205–1242.
101. Schanzenbach, D. W. (2009).
Experimental estimates of the barriers
to food stamp enrollment (Discussion
Paper No. 1367-09). Madison, WI:
Institute for Research on Poverty.
102. U.S. Department of the Treasury,
Internal Revenue Service. (2017).
Form W-4 (2017) (Cat. No. 10220Q).
Retrieved from
103. U.S. Department of the Treasury,
Internal Revenue Service. (2016). IRS
withholding calculator. Retrieved
104. Schepanski, A., & Shearer, T. (1995).
A prospect theory account of the
income tax withholding phenomenon.
Organizational Behavior and Human
Decision Processes, 63, 174–186.
105. White, J. R. (2012). Tax gap: Sources
of noncompliance and strategies to
reduce it (GAO-12-651T) [Testimony
before the Subcommittee on
Government Organization, Efficiency,
and Financial Management,
Committee on Oversight and
40 behavioral science & policy | volume 3 issue 1 2017
Government Reform, House of
Representatives]. Retrieved from http://
106. Shu, L. L., Mazur, N., Gino, F., Ariely,
D., & Bazerman, M. H. (2012). Signing
at the beginning makes ethics salient
and decreases dishonest self-reports
in comparison to signing at the end.
Proceedings of the National Academy
of Sciences, USA, 109, 15197–15200.
107. Schweitzer, M. E., & Croson, R. (1999).
Curtailing deception: The impact of
direct questions on lies and omissions.
International Journal of Conflict
Management, 10, 225–248.
108. Bankman, J., Nass, C., & Slemrod, J.
B. (2016). Using the “smart return” to
reduce tax evasion and simplify tax
filing. Tax Law Review, 69, 459–484.
109. Atalay, K., Bakhtiar, F., Chueng, S., &
Slonim, R. (2014). Savings and prizelinked
savings accounts. Journal of
Economic Behavior and Organization,
107, 86–106.
110. Kearney, M. S., Tufano, P., Guryan, J., &
Hurst, E. (2011). Making savers winners:
An overview of prize-linked savings
products. In O. S. Mitchell & A. Lusardi
(Eds.), Financial literacy: Implications
for retirement security and the financial
marketplace (pp. 218–240). New York,
NY: Oxford University Press.